With the agreement on the proposed Regulation revising ETS benchmarks, reached last night in Brussels between the European Parliament, the Council and the European Commission in the so-called “trilogue”, the European institutions recognise a principle that the Italian ceramics industry has long advocated: the system used to allocate free allowances, applied indiscriminately across all sectors, …
With the agreement on the proposed Regulation revising ETS benchmarks, reached last night in Brussels between the European Parliament, the Council and the European Commission in the so-called “trilogue”, the European institutions recognise a principle that the Italian ceramics industry has long advocated: the system used to allocate free allowances, applied indiscriminately across all sectors, does not take account of the specific technologies and energy sources actually available to each sector. For years, this has penalised ceramic tile manufacturers using high-temperature processes for which there are currently no alternatives to natural gas. A horizontal benchmark demands the same outcome from everyone, as though all industries had access to the same technologies and energy sources, ultimately penalising those that have already done everything possible with the technologies currently available.
The text provides for an increase in the heat and fuel benchmarks for all European sectors and installations, resulting in more free allowances being allocated during the 2026–2030 period.
The real innovation, however, requested by the European Parliament on 22 October with a broad cross-party majority of 474 MEPs, is the introduction of sector-specific fuel benchmarks within the ETS, to be defined through delegated acts and open, transparent consultations. Although not explicitly mentioned, the ceramic tile industry is the leading candidate to benefit from a specific benchmark, which must finally remedy the unfair under-allocation of allowances that our companies have suffered to date, as acknowledged by the European Commission itself.
“After months of work, discussions and dialogue with the institutions, we are finally seeing recognition of a sound argument that we have pursued with determination: the ETS must be corrected, otherwise it will fail to achieve its environmental objectives and leave industrial devastation in local communities,” says Augusto Ciarrocchi, President of Confindustria Ceramica. “This is the result of a coordinated effort across the system, achieved together with Confindustria under the leadership of Emanuele Orsini. We thank MEPs from all political parties, who listened to and embraced the sector’s arguments, and the Government, which, through the consistently active work of our Permanent Representation, held its ground effectively and firmly in the Council, despite the objective difficulties arising from divergent interests among EU countries. The stance taken by the Emilia-Romagna Region and the municipalities of the district was also fundamental. They were on the front line in stating a simple truth: jobs, businesses and local communities would pay the price of a flawed rule.”
“The agreed text is an important step, and what matters now is that it is implemented at the right time and in the right way,” adds Graziano Verdi, President of the European Ceramic Industry Federation. “In practical terms, the sector-specific adjustment can only be determined in 2028, but the text rightly provides for the adjustment to also cover 2026 and 2027. We will now continue to monitor the Commission’s work to ensure the full implementation of the principles established by yesterday’s trilogue. For the competitiveness of our companies, we cannot accept unjustified additional ETS costs on top of the already severe impact of energy costs.”
The compromise must now be formally adopted by the European Parliament in plenary and by the Council, so that the new benchmarks can be applied with retroactive effect from 1 January 2026 as soon as possible.
“The European ceramics industry has shown that it can be part of the transition, provided the rules are fair and sustainable,” concludes Ciarrocchi. “We have seen administrations and political representatives from different groups, with widely differing views on the ETS, come together around a legitimate demand. Yet all of them have worked, each in their own role, towards an outcome that provides tangible protection for businesses and jobs in our local communities.”

Background
Companies covered by the EU ETS must surrender “emission allowances” for every tonne of CO2 (or equivalent) emitted. Installations in sectors considered at risk of relocation receive free allowances based on benchmarks established by the Commission. These benchmarks reflect the average performance of the 10% most efficient installations manufacturing a given product.
Where no product-specific benchmarks exist, free allocation is mainly based on heat and fuel consumption (the “fallback benchmarks”).
The benchmark values for the 2026–2030 period have been updated, introducing drastic cuts to free allowances that result in additional costs for companies required to comply with benchmarks that do not reflect their actual performance.
For further information on the content of the agreement reached, see:

